Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Marijuana as an alcohol substitute...please think twice before trying!

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Marijuana as an alcohol substitute...please think twice before trying!

    Hi all, I've been AF for over 11 weeks now but have been using marijuana at night as a direct alcohol replacement. I'm writing this for the benefit of anyone else who may be doing this or considering it. Please understand that this is not intended as a lecture to anyone.

    I was never a pot smoker before this time, apart from minor experimental use. I was a very heavy nightly drinker and alcoholic, 20-22 standard drinks per night. I drank initially as a method of temporary escape from emotional problems like depression, loneliness, shyness, and anxiety. Insomnia has always been a problem aswell. I spoke to numerous doctors, counsellors, and psychologists/psychiatrists over the years and was prescribed nearly all the antidepressants, but in all cases without any substantial success. Alcohol remained the only thing that "worked" for me, but the tolerance and huge intake ended up making the drinking an almost entirely negative experience. Apart from all the hangovers, liver damage, and general disruption of life, the alcohol ceased having much of an effect on me apart from making me feel sick. It stopped producing any noticeable buzz or high, and I couldn't even escape into an emotional fantasy any more because I could no longer get drunk from it (unless I drank an enormous amount that left me totally ill and unable to legally drive a car for over 24 hours).

    In January this year I underwent a successful outpatient alcohol detox using diazepam (Valium) and proceeded to try baclofen. I quickly gave up on baclofen due to an unfortunate insomniac reaction to it (luckily it helps most people sleep). I had tried naltrexone via TSM last year but had not given it a long enough trial, since I gave up after only a month or less. I began to smoke cannabis at night in place of alcohol, to try and keep my depression under control aswell as to get high. I didn't even like the effects of MJ to begin with, and still don't find it very much like drunkenness, but it was the only buzz available to me. I now realise that I was seriously mistaken to keep on trying to live in an emotional fantasy world and keep on chasing a chemical high. My life has not progressed in any meaningful way, certainly not in the way I was hoping for after quitting alcohol. MJ has also been making me extremely tired as an after-effect. I spend each day in a mental fog and can definitely notice the dulling effect on my mind; everyday activities can be a real effort. MJ also gives me unpleasant effects during the high, such as anxiety, ringing in the ears, a headache, and an inability to get to sleep for about an hour after going to bed. I toss and turn in bed and my mind races.

    I realise that my personal experience with marijuana may not be the same as that of other people, but I wanted to post this to give an example of why MJ substitution of alcohol may not work out. It may seem like a great idea to start with, even a logical idea, but for me it just hasn't worked out. I still experience depression during the day and find myself white-knuckling my way through sobriety during the times I'm not actually stoned. Some people would probably try smoking more MJ throughout the day to cope, but smoking just at night is already causing me way too many problems. My only obvious choice now is to try baclofen again and possibly use some other drug at night for insomnia, while taking my last dose of baclofen several hours before bedtime. Addressing my other problems in non-chemical ways is also a vital step I must take.

    I will add one more thing, that would probably be fervently denied by most people who are smokers...marijuana can and does cause physical withdrawal symptoms and severe cravings if it is stopped after regular use. I found this out by accident while staying temporarily out of town, about a month into sobriety from alcohol and therefore a month into nightly MJ use. I experienced almost total insomnia as soon as I didn't smoke at night, aswell as serious anxiety and a range of other symptoms that were very similar to moderate alcohol withdrawals. I wouldn't have believed this if someone else had told me, but I know it wasn't a placebo response, since I had never read about MJ withdrawal (I had naively assumed it didn't really exist). Tolerance has also been setting in, which is something else I had assumed was very minimal with MJ. With larger amounts has come more severe tiredness and other unwanted effects. I am also being considered for a new job, and apart from being concerned about MJ inhibiting my ability to work, I am also worried I may have to undergo a drug test. This will prevent me from getting the job since cannabis gives a positive drug test result weeks or even months after being used. I live in a fairly small close-knit community, so failing this drug test is likely to result in me becoming known around town as a 'druggie'. All these problems may not have existed if I had stuck with the baclofen and found ways to work around its few side effects.

    All I can say is that anyone who is thinking of using MJ as an alcohol substitute may find that it does not work out as hoped, and may find that it has too many annoying or debilitating negative effects.

    #2
    Marijuana as an alcohol substitute...please think twice before trying!

    Thank you for taking the time to post. I must say, it did cross my mind but sense I don't know any "dealers" and it's illegal in my part of the world -- it didn't easily come to fruition. Let's create the slogan here: "Give Bac a Chance" and let's be hopeful that we all have the fortunate results that so many MYO users have had.

    Comment


      #3
      Marijuana as an alcohol substitute...please think twice before trying!

      Hi Greg,

      I considered using marijuana as a substitute but decided not to because I didn't want to swap one drug for another. (I've used various illegal drugs in the past, so I'm not anti-drugs, I just wanted to get totally sober).

      And if you're sitting at home every night getting stoned it's doing nothing to end your isolation and help your confidence, is it?

      Greg;836265 wrote: Addressing my other problems in non-chemical ways is also a vital step I must take.
      Yes, that's key. One day we all have to face our problems unless we keep ourselves drugged up for the rest of our lives. And being drugged up (including being drunk) is no way to live, I don't think.
      sigpic
      AF since December 22nd 2008
      Real change is difficult, and slow, and messy - Oliver Burkeman

      Comment


        #4
        Marijuana as an alcohol substitute...please think twice before trying!

        I had only read a couple of lines of this and remembered I too tried the same thing some years ago. Basically when I first realised I was having alcohol issues I was recommended MJ by a couple of people, they argued alcohol was the problem whilst MJ had no harmful effects. I've never been able to smoke I can't stand the feeling of smoke in my lungs so would consume it orally. I already had some experience of the drug and thought why not.

        So what did happen?I simply used it to knock myself out - would take too much and pass out, felt awful in the morning afterwards almost like a zombie. That experiment didn't last long.

        Basically if you have a problem with one substance it's highly likely you will with another mind-altering or psychoactive drug. I also don't like the affects of sedatives in any form and see getting sober as just that - removing all the things I might use to mask feelings and get down to learning to cope with life.

        Glad you have come through this and that you can share this so others might avoid going through the same thing.

        Comment


          #5
          Marijuana as an alcohol substitute...please think twice before trying!

          Thank you for sharing Greg. I, too, want to deal with my problems in a "natural" way and without chemicals or drugs. But still, I am constantly looking for "replacements" for alcohol -- anything that is less harmful and less addictive is a better alternative, I figure... once I get off the alcohol, it will be easier to get off the less addictive substance, is my twisted, but rather logical, thinking. (I haven't tried MJ because it would be close to impossible to get it where I live, and smoking makes me ill.)

          I am at the point where I know I can't succeed on the route of "replacement" because, quite simply, I can't find that replacement, and meanwhile, I am delaying dealing with the real problems.

          However, like you Greg, I have had life-long severe insomnia (and anxiety). At first, Baclofen helped me sleep great -- it was unbelievable. and I had no somnolence during the day. It was a miracle for the insomnia (less so for the drinking). But now, at higher doses, it agitates me and I have been sleeping badly for months, even after moving my last dose to early evening.

          I know I've said this before, but for any of you out there with sleeping problems (who haven't read my previous posts about this):

          There are many, many "natural" sleep aids. I have tried about 10 of them, with mixed results, and I have listed them and reviewed them (based on my personal experience) in the Holistic Healing forum.
          Your time is limited, so don't waste it living someone else's life... And most important, have the courage to follow your heart and intuition. They somehow already know what you truly want to become. Everything else is secondary.

          Steve Jobs, Stanford Commencement Adress, 2005

          Comment


            #6
            Marijuana as an alcohol substitute...please think twice before trying!

            hi greg,thnx for the story,very sad,i wish you well,gyco

            Comment


              #7
              Marijuana as an alcohol substitute...please think twice before trying!

              Hi Greg. I'm really glad you shared your MJ substitution experience as I think it's very "logical" that we AL dependent people consider finding alternatives for our high. (in the "logical" way only us AL dependent people can think! :H)

              I have heard many people at AA warn against "The MJ Solution" as well - it just seems to cause more trouble than it solves in the long run."

              My husband is one of those annoying people who drinks "a" beer on occassion (yes, as in ONE - something I have never been able to do!). BUT...he smoked MJ since his college years and had a horrible time stopping. It might not addict everyone, but I think it sure addicts some. (like AL..)

              This is a good thread and message for anyone else that might be considering this approach.

              Strength and hope to you in your quest for sobriety Greg!

              DG
              Sobriety Date = 5/22/08
              Nicotine Free Date = 2/27/07


              One day at a time.

              Comment


                #8
                Marijuana as an alcohol substitute...please think twice before trying!

                greg thank you so much for this post.
                i was thinking about changing from alcohol to something else at some point and MJ crossed my mind. i figured that my body just wanted to feel numb, and falling asleep totally tired. luckily it is super mega illegal here and i would not have considered MJ because of the very likely sevre legal impact.

                Bac really did the job for me.
                since 23. Apr 2009 : TSM - failed to reduce units
                since 08. Jan 2010 : Naltrexone + Baclofen combination therapy
                reborn since 16. Jan 2010 : Alcohol Free (AF) - only taking Baclofen
                since 22. May 2010 : Baclofen against anxiety/fear
                since 14. Mar 2011 : off Baclofen - taking 25mg Topamax/day

                My stats :
                http://www.baclofen-forum.com/stats/craving/

                Comment


                  #9
                  Marijuana as an alcohol substitute...please think twice before trying!

                  I had some unpleasant experiences when trying to subsitute MJ for AL. The basic problem was my craving was for AL and MJ didnt even come close to giving me what I wanted. The nice, warm, Ahhh feeling when the alcohol level is just right in the bloodstream and I havent blacked out, passed out, puked on my mother in laws sofa etc etc.

                  The MJ experiment was one (from some years ago) that just didnt work. However I have a habit of repeating failed experiemnts...

                  Now - reading this today I am pleasantly surprised to find that in response to reading this thread I have a total disinterest in smoking weed. I think that is down to BAC. A bit like DR A not buying the CD and only realising afterwards that he hadnt. I think pre BAC reading this would have set off a chain of thought on how to try and make MJ work for me this time round.

                  Yay.
                  Andy R:

                  Comment


                    #10
                    Marijuana as an alcohol substitute...please think twice before trying!

                    I could never imagine smoking weed as as sub for AL. It makes me so paranoid and I've had some major panic attacks on it. IMO they are 2 totally different buzzes. I smoked it like a trooper for about 10 years when I was younger and my whole life revolved around it but I just became disalousioned with it.
                    Started TSM 07/12 Pre TSM... 50-100 UK units

                    Drinking under control. Still shooting for abstinence.

                    Comment


                      #11
                      Marijuana as an alcohol substitute...please think twice before trying!

                      Hi Greg,

                      Great Post.

                      Also went through this experiment for a while last year while I was sober. (actually not intitially.) And while it gave me a bit of the satisfaction I was looking for (being near knocked out) I eventually smoked way too much one evening and had the scariest experience. I think I thought I was dying I was so out of my mind.

                      Anycase, interesting with the substitution topic as well. I've found myself endulging (and over indulging) in coffee, which gives a great buzz for a while but landing up in an emotional down a couple of hours later.

                      What to do when you have an addictive personality?

                      Good luck
                      AF since 15th March 2010

                      The journey is the goal. As long as you're fighting the good fight and you're not giving up on giving up, you're winning. It's not about how often you get knocked down, it's about how often you get up again. Sobriety the goal for sure. But striving to get to that goal is what it's about. Not getting there. Because the journey never ends. The journey is the goal.

                      Comment


                        #12
                        Marijuana as an alcohol substitute...please think twice before trying!

                        Thank's for sharing that Greg, and thankyou too Beatle for your suggestions.
                        Wishing you a smoother road to recovery Greg.
                        Hang in there brother, you'll make it.

                        'I am part of all that I have met, yet all experience is an arch wherethro', gleams that untravelled world whose margins fade, forever and forever when I move'

                        Zen soul Warrior. Freedom today-

                        Comment


                          #13
                          Marijuana as an alcohol substitute...please think twice before trying!

                          Thanks folks for the replies and encouragement.

                          I'm glad people realise that MJ is not likely to work as an AL substitute. AA members used to warn me about 'swapping the witch for the bitch' as they like to call it but I still went ahead with trying it. I'm just glad I didn't have to waste even more years of my life before I woke up that it wasn't working out.

                          I'm now seeing a therapist/shrink to work on my underlying problems and I'm also trying AA again. While I'm not really an 'AAer' I have found some meetings to be quite helpful.

                          Comment

                          Working...
                          X